What is the purpose of using a head-to-head ballot rather than a ranked ballot for a three-candidate election? What are its positive features? How does ballot rotation ensure every candidate is treated fairly? How are mismarked ballots handled in a head-to-head system?
A new research note by Charles Munger, Jr. explains why we use a head-to-head ballot in Better Choices for Democracy’s proposed Top Three election system. Top Three includes an all-voter primary and a three-candidate head-to-head ballot in the general election.
Better Choices for Democracy recognizes that clear ballot interpretation rules are essential to public understanding, confidence in election results, and accurate tabulation. Voters should know that each valid head-to-head choice counts independently, including when their choices form a cycle, and that an unanswered comparison remains unanswered rather than being filled in on their behalf. These rules also give election administrators and voting-system vendors explicit requirements for programming, testing, and auditing the count. Policymakers should establish the rules in advance and document their reasoning and tradeoffs so the public can understand how ballots are counted and evaluate whether the rules have been applied consistently, including in a close or disputed election.
Read below for eleven highlights as to why Top Three uses head-to-head ballots, or read the full research note by Charles Munger, Jr. here.